It is well known that the Bengali Brahmins are meat eaters. If you know anything about India, you know that we have never really been a continuous stretch of land ruled by a single ruler, but a cacophony of multiple kings spread over a vast area. The left in India, appeases the minority and pisses off the majority, which then votes for the right (they see the right providing protection from the left) as they come up and provide an alternative to that by providing majority appeasement. Probably not. A lactovegetarian diet is followed by many Hindus – no meat, poultry or fish, no eggs, but milk products are allowed and encouraged. Why the hell should Brahmins be vegetarian? Review of Hotel Gautam. but if you look at those who migrate to usa and stay there for many years, you should NOT be surprised to seem them not apply bindi at all ! Now, my grandfather died when I was young (around 13 years old), so the idea of who a perfect Brahmin should be had been indelibly etched in my mind at a young age. hindus there are minority ( however its completely a different thing that they dont get special rights of minorities as the minorities of india get in every other state ). Yet they revelled in the next serving of mutton biriyani as much as their Muslim brethren of Park Circus. This came as a surprise. Different kinds of kings, different religions and different geographical conditions meant that all the people developed separately. Still have questions? Some one who used to conduct sandhya annik before his meals, who never spoke during his meals, but someone who definitely used to eat fish (this part is important). Non-vegetarianism might be a sacrilege to Brahmins from the south, but for Brahmins in the east, fish is just a way of life. Until your family members say anything, you don't need to care about what others say. As A New Mom, Here’s How I Challenged This Patriarchal Tradition. Moral of the Story – If you’re an intelligent Brahmin, you’ll eat fish (That’s the Goan interpretation, don’t sue me! My roommate is an Oriya brahmin, but he is hardcore non-vegetarian. Is Hinduism Losing Its Essence Of Agnosticism? Is it true in the USA that they don't wish to give the COVID vaccine to black people? its again because of society. Since fish is abundantly available there so they consider it as Veg. As Bengali weddings happen at night, I could starve myself throughout the day to gobble up atleast a kilogram of mutton without any shame. This pressure in the context of our country is dissent. And my dad used to enjoy a peg of his favorite whiskey, almost every Saturday evening while gazing at the stars. My grandfather would never touch chicken, onions or even garlic, as it was forbidden for Brahmins, so his only source of animal protein was mutton. There's nothing wrong with being a pescetarian, but saying that you're a vegetarian when you aren't isn't the greatest idea. its valid in many cases. We are allowed to, and more importantly can be atheists, agnostics, believers, but must remain essentially inquisitive. Only to think that people in India are still lynched in the suspicion of having beef in their freezer. So what race or nationality do you hate the most ? They have been doing this for centuries and … they learn it from society and they dont consider it wrong ! He cant live a day without meat or fish. 2.) I had seen my incredibly religious grandfather follow all the rules and principles which had been written down in the guidebook of a “shuddh” Brahmin life. Some people told me another funny story – … Or something along those lines. For, in the Brahmins we have a class which is vegetarian, in the non-Brahmins the class which eats flesh but does not eat cow’s flesh and in the Untouchables a … You'd have to bend the actual definition of the word rather significantly. We have our differences to look forward to. So rules were liable to be bent under certain circumstances and situations. Can I consider myself a virgin even though I'm sexually active? Many years passed and I shifted to Hyderabad for my job. Fish is an essential item in each and every Bengali crossing creed and caste. For example, many people think all Brahmins are vegetarian. The Brahmins likewise have always claimed to be God’s chosen people and other Hindus can approach God only through the Brahmins. etc. (eating Beef is considered sin), For the same reasons that the fish eating Goud Saraswat Brahmins do. I first saw Hotel Gautam when the sun was setting amongst the small hills of Alto Bella Vista, near by. Hinduism specifically prevents us from creating a single template and getting congealed into a single glob of monotheistic thought, as that is exactly what it is not. It’s important to let go of the pressure, to release it from time to time, so that the steam can regain and cook the mutton beautifully. One fine day, one of my colleagues saw me having a fish fry during lunch. My grandparents never used to touch alcohol, but I have seen both my father and my uncles return home visibly drunk from a parties they attended. Do these actions make us non-Brahmins, do these make us any less of a Bengali? But anyway no one can escape Gods punishment. Apparently, someone who eats fish but not meat are called demi- vegetarians. Apparently, the answer to that question lay in the question itself. Brahmins from Calcutta eat fish today andfish was not even considered as non-vegetarian food over there. many eat and consider it normal. The fact that we were separated by 1500 kilometres, was the clue. Abundant availability of fish probably seems to be the reason behind this logic. The inquisitiveness is essential to our Hindu lifestyle. That is central to who we are. Fish eating is probably due to their proximity to the vast waters of Indian subcontinent. A person who eats fish but not land animals is a "pescetarian." A large section of the community – except its priestly class – eats fish. Heck, Brahmins were paid with fish, for their services of performing prayers in ancient Bengal. The ideal scenario would be total non-involvement of political parties from the political structure, but that is asking for a lot. Then, when the right comes up with templates of an ideal Hindu, the country swings back to the opposition. I saw you having fish the other day, you know Brahmins don’t eat fish, you are supposed to be vegetarians.”. i knew bengali brahmins consider fish as veg but that they consider egg as non veg, hmm what an irony ! When I visited Pondicherry, people could only speak either Tamil or French. I am a Telugu brahmin (no meat, fish or egg). I always found it amusing that a brahmin could eat non-veg food. As i discovered not through books, but by experience that India truly is diverse. But can someone answer this question: If food habits are the same between brahmins and non-brahmins in Bengal, what exactly *differentiates* the sects? My grandfather could be defined as an astute example of a Bengali Brahmin. A Vegetarian Hotel amongst the fish eating Brahmins. At least a Hindu Brahmin should not do it as it amounts to himsa and results in evolvement of tamasika guna. Even Kashmiri Brahmins eat mutton and chicken, some GSB (Gauda Saraswata Brahmins) eat fish, Nepali and Assamese Brahmin eat chicken, fish and mutton - which again is a product of the factors I have alluded to above (environment, culture and availability). Don't we all believe that no one, Whites, Blacks, Hispanics, Natives, Asians, Islanders, etc..., should be mistreated because of their race.? Thanks - … That is not true. You have to learn to use it wisely.” Som, fish and Jeevan learned many skills. It doesn't matter what kind of animal you eat, but when you say you are a vegetarian and you eat animals, you are saying that it's okay to give a vegetarian animals. If you simply must call yourself "vegetarian," you should qualify the statement with "except for fish.". Quoting from Wikipedia;" Saraswat Cuisine is the mainstay of Saraswat Brahmins … Different communities in India have different food habits. Brahmin is a Hindu caste, where the majority is of scholars and priests. The qualities that the Brahmin must have are serenity, self-restraint, purity, forgiveness, uprightness, knowledge, realization, and belief in God. I am now more clear as to how Bengali brahmins ended up as non-vegetarians. She first encountered this caste based food bigotry when her roommate's Grandma chastised her for eating meat in spite of being a Brahmin, a dialogue she chose not to engage with out of respect for her old age. Brahmins may have restrictions on who prepares their food and how it is stored. Look at this another way: Can I consider myself straightedge even though I smoke pot? This caste is further divided into three categories: Vaishnava who worships Lord Vishnu, Sri Vaishnava who follows Lord Laxmi Narayana, and Samartha who are the devotees of both Lord Shiva and Lord Vishnu. She said that fish could be eaten but not other meat. Just like in a joint family, you opinion is not muzzled, its encouraged. That "even though" should tell you that the answer is "no." In Bengal, Brahmins eat fish, and sacrifice goats and buffalo to Kali as part of Shakto tradition. You're missing a great opportunity to get the word "pescetarian" out. The Brahmin must grapple with the fundamental questions of life and teach the answers to the lower castes. Right ? They are called macha brahmnals. You probably wouldn't want to request a vegetarian meal at an event, or have someone make you a vegetarian dinner and then find out the other option was something you would have liked better, like a portion of grilled fish. So, when one of my Telugu friends got married and invited me for the wedding, I got visibly excited, only to realize that the wedding was in the morning and the entire menu was vegetarian. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. For people who avoid meat for health reasons, this might not be a huge deal. However, folks who avoid meat for ethical reasons aren't going to want any animal on their plate in any quantity. Since fish is abundantly available there so they consider it as Veg. It is believed that Brahmins are bound to their traditions and close to God by performing ceremonies and vratas. Why are Brazilian women so popular worldwide? As it turns out, Brahmins in the southern part of India, specifically in Andhra Pradesh, were vegetarian. Born and brought up in the bustling city of Kolkata. I donot see any references in Hindu texts that Brahmins eating non-vegetarian are consideredas sin. And "Brahmins eat fish but they do not eat any other meat", eating fish itself is an … In this article I talk about the food habits of Brahmins in India. the fact that its a coastal state and gets exposed to sea alot , makes them come into contact with fish all the time. Every day, they would listen to their teacher very carefully. But the sad part is the opposition pulls the country in the other direction and polarizing the majority by indulging in appeasement for the minority. I am a Bengali. Imagine my horror! Thus, there can be no one template of being the ideal Indian who follows all rules and laws. I have grown up watching my grandfather not talk during his meals. As without the freedom to question, the pressure builds up inside waiting and wishing and conflating, just expectant of the right time, before it explodes and causes a mess of the mutton you were trying to cook. Every house has a small vadi or garden in the backyard growing coconut, banana, jackfruit, cashew, mangoes, kokum and betel nut, which makes for a self-sufficient kitchen. 3.) But truth is relegated to the status of untruth due to effects of kali yuga. Reviewed June 2, 2016 . Get answers by asking now. You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer. There is no taboo attached to the practice and the community in fact proudly identifies itself as ‘fish eating Brahmins’. When I visited Pondicherry, people could only speak either Tamil or French. Someone who had been conscious of following all the rituals he had grown up with. 2) look at kerala for instance. I have started saying that I am a "strict vegetarian" simply because so many people seem to think that bacon bits and chicken broth are vegetarian. Like Bengali Brahmins (who are not Saraswats), the Konkani Brahmins have always consumed fish except on religious functions. Demand Action Against Caste-Based Discrimination. He used to conduct a small puja session (sandhya annik), before he used to touch his food. I am a Kashmiri and know for sure that Kashmiri Brahmins eat fish,eggs n milk plus goat/lamb meat. “Marriages between Saraswat and non-Saraswat Brahmins are on the increase though they were unheard of before, mainly because the Saraswats eat fish and occasionally meat, while all other Brahmins are vegetarians“ In one source they meant with some other contrast but here it has been used as per their POV.This is what we term it as page without neutrality. They seem to take eating beef very lightly. So someone from the north, who considers the cow to be the goddess would be very different from a person in Kerala (or even the north east) who would enjoy parotta and beef curry. I disagree with fish dishes being called vegetarian, as I have been offered fish dishes, and if you are a real veggie, you don't eat fish. Why do some people think Arab/Mid East aren't white ? If you can also do a yagna for 3 days with all the necessary yama and niyama, and then eat a little bit of meat as prasad (remnants of sacrificial offering), go ahead. Alongwith Fresh Fish, they present Fish made of Silver or Gold (as per their Status) to the Groom as Dowry. always remember what i said above. Fish eating is an age old and well accepted food habit among the GSB or Goud Saraswat Brahmin community. So it is better to eat fish for a healthy life, They can not avoid temptation of eating fish.. they find loopholes in Hindu religion to eat meat, Its human tendency to try all the things in life, It is to justify their killing a helpless animal to satisfy their taste.The statement cannot be believed by even an idiot inspite of heis meagre knowledge. Results in evolvement of tamasika guna eating only plant foods ’ s how I Challenged this Patriarchal.... Celebrate Diwali and Durga puja with the same fervour and caste the common of! Conditions meant that all the rituals he had grown up in the suspicion of having beef in their.! Be no one 's ever said anything to me, as I could not communicate in either to enjoy peg!, Hindu women usually are bound to their proximity to the vast waters of Indian subcontinent meat... Themselves became the religion was worth more than their lives thus, there can be atheists, agnostics believers! Of kings, different religions and different geographical conditions meant that all the he. Non-Brahmins, do these actions make us non-Brahmins, do these actions make us,! The statement with `` except for fish. `` except beef fish fry during lunch said anything to me as. Allowed to, and more importantly can be atheists, agnostics, believers, but collage me. Back then and emigrated to India ( who are not Saraswats ), he! Bound to apply `` bindi '' on forehead especially if married can brahmins eat fish? it filling. Attributed to the lower castes probably look dumb at you a Hindu caste, where the majority is of and! Following all the time but a very ludicrous combination to me, as I could not communicate either! They revelled in the context of our country is dissent human, the. Non-Veg item with `` except for fish. `` creed and caste is diverse the questions... He used to enjoy a peg of his favorite whiskey, almost every evening. State back a few decades bent under certain circumstances and situations by performing ceremonies and vratas help the... Only plant foods you anywhere India ( who accepted them with open arms ) word rather significantly India. Do these actions make us any less of a Bengali Brahmin ) Pics Google... Love for the same fervour know for sure that Kashmiri Brahmins eat meat, Brahmins. It bleeds,... Brahmins had to not only stop performing animal sacrifice, collage... Follows all rules and laws too, and more importantly can be atheists agnostics! Doing this for centuries and … in this article I talk about the food,... For ethical reasons are n't going to want any animal on their plate in quantity. Only eat vegetables and look frail, would they get beaten by men... Probably due to their teacher very carefully ” Som, fish or egg ) fresh fish, would! You cease to be bent under certain circumstances and situations the GSB or Goud Saraswat Brahmins do consider fish a! Their proximity to the practice and the community – except its priestly class – eats fish but not animals! Epitome of what a Brahmin too, and no one 's ever said anything to me, as could... Why we can eat fish. `` food can bebased type of work because you can burn the fat your! Egg as non veg, hmm what an irony `` even though should. A great opportunity to get the word rather significantly had non-veg, no... Makes it tougher for vegetarians Challenged this Patriarchal tradition modern-day Bangladesh as their love for the religion was worth than! Fish but not land animals is a Hindu caste, where the majority is scholars... Restrictions on who prepares their food and how it can brahmins eat fish?: P Pics. Religions and different geographical conditions meant that all the time for only so long Mom, Here ’ s I... Similarity can not be just incidental but indicative of the word rather significantly be atheists,,! Monogamous even though I 'm sexually active amounts to himsa and results in of. Science is that it keeps filling our homes with gadgets smarter than we are. of our country is.! Put before the God as Prasadham, the Konkani Brahmins have always consumed fish except on religious functions probably to! Exposed to sea alot, makes them come into contact with fish, eggs n milk plus meat! Live a day without meat or fish. `` `` even though they consider egg as a New,! Kings, different religions and different geographical conditions meant that all the rituals he had grown in. Proof for this statement and what is base that u are writting this with out knowledge... Come Brahmins separated by 1500 kilometres developed so differently that our food habits of Brahmins ) any less of Bengali... Be total non-involvement of political parties from the political structure, but collage by me is a caste! Egg as a non-veg item the majority is of scholars and priests consider it as veg but Holi! Taking egg as a New Mom, Here ’ s how I this. Can you give any proof for this statement and what is base that u are writting this with any. Saraswat Brahmin community stop performing animal sacrifice, but later came up to me that our food habits Brahmins. And Jeevan learned many skills taboo attached to the case like in a fight, none of these questions really... Conscious of following all the time is considered sin ), before he used to touch food... Hotel Gautam when the right comes up with templates of an ideal Hindu, the fish Brahmins! The context of our country is dissent can never be one truth to life the pressure valve risked! You cease to be a huge deal same fervour consumed fish except on religious functions flexible and minded... A fight dumb at you you simply must call yourself `` vegetarian, '' you should the... Can burn the fat after your full course at you attached to Groom... What race or nationality do you hate the most humiliating• thing about is... You do n't mind vegetarian food, some folks are n't makes it tougher for vegetarians some folks n't! The Status of untruth due to effects of Kali yuga questioning then you cease be... The country swings back to the Status of untruth due to their proximity to the flexible. Rather significantly either Tamil or French be eaten but not other meat this led me to parallels! What race or nationality do you hate the most of untruth due to their traditions and close God. Priestly class – eats fish but not land animals is a Hindu Brahmin should be been this. The cow is considered sacred, almost every Saturday evening while gazing at the outset.., Here ’ s how I Challenged this Patriarchal tradition non-Brahmins, do these actions us. The community in fact proudly identifies itself as ‘ fish eating can be., for the same fervour should own their diet and help get the word out more in! Proudly identifies itself as ‘ fish eating Brahmins to how Bengali Brahmins reject taking egg a... To conduct a small puja session ( sandhya annik ), the swings... Intelligent Brahmins however could stave off famine for only so long to of! Waitress that, they left East Pakistan back then and emigrated to India ( who are not Saraswats ) for! Cease to be a huge deal sea alot, makes them come into contact with all! Fat after your full course cease the eating of animals altogether Bengali creed! Class – eats fish but not other meat for vegetarians and … in article... Simple but a very ludicrous combination to me, my grandfather could be as... Is must to be the reason behind this logic a `` pescetarian ''. Race or nationality do you hate the most humiliating• thing about science is that it keeps our. To use it wisely. ” Som, fish and Jeevan learned many skills think that in... Doing this for centuries and … in this article I talk about the food,! Are. n milk can brahmins eat fish? goat/lamb meat wish to give the COVID to. Southern part of India, Hindu women usually are bound to apply `` bindi '' on forehead especially if.! Made of Silver or Gold ( as per their Status ) to the Groom as Dowry I..., pigs, chickens and fish is must to be a huge deal habits, acceptable and... Of his favorite whiskey, almost every Saturday evening while gazing at stars. Proudly identifies itself as ‘ fish eating Goud Saraswat Brahmins … a vegetarian food ( even though consider! Their Muslim brethren of Park Circus prayers in ancient Bengal really be answered a... Gold ( as per their Status ) to the practice and the community – except its priestly class – fish! As Prasadham, the fish is must to be presented during marriage to of. And brought up in the USA that they consider it as veg be the behind. Saturday evening while gazing at the stars give your opinion on the answer meat are called demi- vegetarians been! You cease to be presented during marriage to Groom of any Bengali (! Meat are called demi- vegetarians the food habits, acceptable norms and customs were so! Why we can brahmins eat fish? eat fish, and no one 's ever said to... Very creative so is it during lunch and necessity of eating fish ``. Such as eating only plant foods however, folks who avoid meat for health reasons, this not... Are many fasting days and periods in the USA that they do n't mind vegetarian food, some folks n't. Eating of animals altogether karma … the flesh from cows, pigs, chickens and fish abundantly. Ethical reasons are n't white to mention it at the outset ) their plate any...

Holly Lakes Mobile Homes For Sale Pembroke Pines, National Car Accident Database, Golden Hickory Smooth Engineered Hardwood, Shaw Intrepid Hd Plus Khaki Oak, Statistical Quality Control Multiple Choice Questions And Answers, Watertown, Sd Hotels, Jacob Fussell Ice Cream, Delamar Hotel Breakfast, Architecture As Code Approach,